NYC Transit Workers Need to Remember: Governor Hochul Twice Killed the “Death Gamble” Bill That Would Have Protected Their Pensions

Every NYC Transit and MaBSTOA employee needs to remember what happened when it comes time to vote for Governor in November.
Governor Kathy Hochul vetoed the NYC Transit “Death Gamble” Bill—not once, but twice.
The legislation was designed to protect transit workers who had reached retirement eligibility but chose to continue working. Under the bill, if a NYC Transit Authority employee was eligible for a service retirement and died while still working, their beneficiary could receive an enhanced benefit based on the pension the employee had earned, rather than being limited to the ordinary in-service death benefit.
The bill passed both houses of the New York State Legislature with overwhelming bipartisan support—62-0 in the Senate and 146-0 in the Assembly in 2025—before Governor Hochul vetoed it on December 19, 2025. The Legislature had passed a substantially similar version the previous year, which Hochul also vetoed in December 2024.
This issue became very real to me again recently when I spoke with a recently retired high-ranking manager from the Department of Subways. He was only 55 years old and did not necessarily want to retire. But he was concerned that by continuing to work after becoming retirement-eligible, he was taking a gamble with the pension benefits his family would receive if something happened to him before he officially retired.
Think about that.
A transit worker can spend 25, 30 or more years dedicating their life to keeping New York moving, reach retirement eligibility, and still have to ask themselves whether continuing to work could put their family’s pension security at risk.
That is exactly why the Death Gamble legislation mattered.
The New York State Senate’s own legislative summary described the bill as modifying the in-service death benefit for retirement-eligible NYC Transit Authority members and allowing beneficiaries to receive the greater of the applicable lump-sum or monthly retirement benefit.
Governor Hochul had two opportunities to protect these workers and their families. She vetoed the legislation both times.
Transit workers have long memories.
When you enter the voting booth this November, remember who stood up for the Death Gamble Bill—and remember who vetoed it.
TWU Local 106 will never forget.
Philip Valenti, President